Hey I spoke with the max club team. Probably not necessary to have a separate forum for the app clubs as that counts towards the Xbox one completions and the Xbox one points leaderboard. It would more than likely just get confusing for members.
Back in the day it never used to be like that but when we all started going over site policy, we changed it to coincide with the rest of the site's policy on it. You can see it noted at the bottom of the FAQs in the max club's rules thread http://www.xboxachievements.com/foru...d.php?t=388302 . I'm assuming you are asking about GEN 10 on Titanfall so yes you would need that achievement to post for the club completion.
Ha, yeah, buuuuut I'm not about to drop sixty on it. I'll either find a place to rent it (do those even exist?) or wait until it's super cheap down the line. Just got Halo Wars to play with a friend, final Borderlands 2 DLC tomorrow as well, plus I have to finish Risen 2 (one achievement left) and I own Witcher 2 untouched.