Do me and everyone a favor and ignore that guy. He has been trolling those sub-forums since day one, and posts everywhere about how great the game is. He can't see it for what it is, or admit to being wrong. I too was hoping for something awesome. While I don't think it is as bad as everyone says it is, it definitely isn't a 5 star game. I would probably give it a 3 and that's being generous, and on top of that it should have been $10, not enough content to warrant a $15 game. However, keep in mind it's the 1st part a trilogy, so there will be two other installments. Still too much money for too little.