XboxAchievements.com

XboxAchievements.com (http://www.xboxachievements.com/forum/index.php)
-   Silent Hill HD Collection (http://www.xboxachievements.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=2471)
-   -   This Or Downpour? (http://www.xboxachievements.com/forum/showthread.php?t=365401)

CalSlayer 04-09-2012 02:28 PM

This Or Downpour?
 
I'm stuck deciding between this or Downpour, I have never played any of the Silent Hill games and have hardly played any Survival Horror Games, I've read some reviews and I've been edged into buying the HD Collection, but I want to know which one has the more in depth story line and the one that is sure to spook me out!

ChickinOnaChain 04-09-2012 02:46 PM

Downpour or flip a coin.

O918 04-09-2012 03:11 PM

im in a similar situation, stuck between downpour or HD, but i have played several silent hills (1,2,4, origins, homecoming). if you want a "newer" experience but dont want to spend the money, im sure you can buy homecoming for $20 or less now. its been several years since i played it, but i really enjoyed it at the time.

I bought the HD collection, but i havent opened it bc I am still deciding whether to take it back and get downpour. i dusted off my ps2 to play the original SH2 to help weigh in on my decision, damn game still creeps me the hell out!

CalSlayer 04-09-2012 03:13 PM

I really do want a game that will creep me the hell out, Dead Space did a fine job of that for me, but I want a different experience, and Im stuck between these 2 games!

Creazil 04-09-2012 03:18 PM

Since Homecoming (or was it Origins), Team Silent wasn't working on the games anymore. Which made Silent Hill controlled by a western developer. Now, SH1, 2, 3 and 4 were all Japanese developers. Japanese is the way to go with horror. SH2 & 3 are easily the greatest Survival Horror games in existence. But then again, it's still hard not to get annoyed at the freezing in this game, especially in 3. Waiting for bosses to die for 5 mins instead of 2 seconds.

CalSlayer 04-09-2012 03:29 PM

I'm edging towards the HD Collection, a lot of people do say Silent Hill 2 was amazing - I'm sure I can withstand glitches!

Herr Shaun 04-09-2012 03:51 PM

I beat Downpour in a couple of days and had no real desire to pick it back up afterwards.

I've been playing this since the day it came out.

This.

CalSlayer 04-09-2012 04:03 PM

I think my mind is set, I shall get this!

sleepymexican45 04-09-2012 08:28 PM

If you've never played an old-school survival horror but are used to modern ones like Dead Space, you might prefer Downpour.
Silent Hill 2 should not be missed though - If you can endure the crap controls and awkward fighting, it's an awesome game!!! :p Not only that, but Silent Hill 3 is in there too, which is probably also better that Downpour.

Personally I'm an old-school survival horror fan, but once I'm finished with the HD collection I think I'll check out Downpour. I bet it'll drop in price very fast.

Buy both!

XoNiNjAlEoNoX 04-10-2012 05:17 PM

SH2 rather goes a psychological path which makes it so unique. Containing atmospheric music and visuals and a very deep deep story, it is definitely one of the best games ever.

Aidexx 04-13-2012 08:18 PM

I'm new to this series, and thanks for the posts here, I think I'll start my SH journey from this collection. I don't really mind about those glitches if the game actually offers a good story and scary atmosphere. Is there a timeline in Silent Hill series or are they totally separated games (no continuity)? I know I shouldn't compare games to movies, but that Silent Hill movie was quite awful. Hopefully the games are much better. :)

Gor1lla 04-13-2012 11:00 PM

Not sure about the most games, but i know that:

Origins->SH1->SH3

The other games don't really fit it. There are hints in all the games that point towards other games, but you don't really miss much, if you don't play one of the others.

If you want to learn more about SH, then read this article about Alessia (the reason for the town being as it is now):
http://silenthill.wikia.com/wiki/Alessa_Gillespie

Sadly, there are spoilers....the german article is better
http://www.silenthillwiki.de/index.php?title=Alessa

Aidexx 04-15-2012 09:12 AM

Thanks for the info, I appreciate it. Read your link through and tried to avoid spoilers, think I succeeded. The story seems to be chilling and it has some serious japanese plot twists in it, so I'll be picking this one up, and then decide whether to play the other SH games.

8BitSoul 04-17-2012 12:59 PM

Silent Hill 2 & 3 are still viewed upon as two of the greatest survival horror experiences ever made. If you haven't played any of them, I would strongly recommend playing them before trying Downpour (or any of the other SH games not made by Team Silent).

Silent Hill 2 without a doubt, has the best story. It's really creepy, and as the story unravels when you go through the game, you start seeing just how well put together the plot is. The atmosphere and music is so well-made, and you go through the entire game with a general feeling of unease. The game doesn't rely on cheap scares and "jump-moments" to creep you out, but with atmosphere, and underlined themes such as rape, incest, molestation, murder and psychosis. Themes that have never been touched upon again by any game (at least to my knowledge).

Silent Hill 3 is a bit weaker in the story department, but excels at one thing extremely well: the visuals. It's just so disturbingly twisted and visually warped compared to anything you've ever seen. Heather's decent into the bowels of madness is a very different experience compared to SH2, but yet very familiar in terms of gameplay mechanics and style. The Alternate Hospital is one of the creepiest places I've ever visited in a videogame, and it is just completely out of this world.

Here's an example:


A lot of complaints have been adressed towards the HD Collection, but it's nowhere near as bad as some make it out to be. I've played through SH2 4 times now, and the only bothersome bugs I've encountered were slight slowdowns when achievements are unlocked, and a few minor audio glitches (audio looping and varying in samplerate). I haven't gotten around to playing SH3 yet, but I can't imagine it being very different from SH2 in terms of bugs and problems. It's nothing gamebreaking, and you shouldn't let these minor problems scare you away from experiencing these amazing games!

Rep 04-27-2012 07:58 PM

Have you made your decision yet?

I haven't played the HD collection, but I have played all of the Silent Hill games. If I were you, I would go pick up the HD collection first and play that. If you liked it, then consider picking up Downpour when you get the chance.

Alan Fake 04-29-2012 02:52 PM

HD all the way, played Downpour and thought it was dirt

Sgt Scyther 05-08-2012 03:30 PM

I know you already made your decision but I would have gone with Downpour. All the technical issues surrounding the HD collection doesn't make it worth the asking price and Downpour is the best Silent Hill game since SH3.

HellspawnRei 05-18-2012 02:20 PM

HD Collection all the way.
Downpour is nothing compared to SH2 and SH3.
And SH2 is the best in the series.



I'm glad you made the right choice.

bob101910 05-18-2012 05:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AltFoot85 (Post 5039426)
Aidexx the Silent Hill movie isn't bad at all, it's basically the first game with a woman instead! The Sean Penn bits were weak but for the most part it was amazingly close to the game.... Especially running through the dark alley surrounded by children. If you disliked the film DO NOT play the games! The games have the same psychological atmosphere and confusing visuals as the film and the plots tend to be very confusing up until the end.... If you didn't like the film you'll hate the games


I liked the movie and haven't played the game yet. Thanks I'll check out the collection. I remember a video trailer of the first game on several demo discs I have for PS1 and they scared the shit out of me.

Direkin 06-12-2012 05:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob101910 (Post 5074696)
I liked the movie and haven't played the game yet. Thanks I'll check out the collection. I remember a video trailer of the first game on several demo discs I have for PS1 and they scared the shit out of me.

I never played the original, but I did see the film. In fact it was the film (plus Alan Wake in a way) that helped me decide to get the HD collection as soon as I saw it.

Devin Caitlyn 06-13-2012 02:52 AM

I'd definitely pick up downpour and just buy these two games (1 and 2) for their original platforms. The collection was very glitchy and really wasn't worth the money.

Madame Kennedy 06-13-2012 11:16 PM

I've heard that the HD Collection was glitchy mainly (and ironically) for PS3 folks. Being a 360 user, I haven't experienced much in the way of glitches, per say. I have come across audio looping, but that's not really an end of the world kind of thing. About the only thing really that upset me with the collection was the changing/removal of certain sounds present in the original PS2 version. For instance, veteran players no doubt knowing, the certain boat horn noise that usually plays when going down a certain looooooong staircase (don't want to spoil for newbies) is no longer there. There's only a bizarre clicking noise amongst silence. Being one of my favorite sounds in the game, that really ticked me off, and I personally don't see Konami planning to fix any of that. If they can't be assed to pay the original voice actors, I doubt they'll commit much more to the gamers.

But anyway, to the initial question at hand, I would personally choose the HD collection over Downpour. In my honest opinion, every Silent Hill game after 4 has pretty much sucked and only diluted the quality of the series. If you want to get the true feeling of Silent Hill, I would DEFINITELY recommend the Collection, hands down.

Catwoman 10-18-2012 11:19 AM

silent hill games are awesome
 
Silent Hill Downpour is okay, although it is not very scary. It is a short game, and I completed it in 2 days, I like the Otherworld parts of the game though, but I thought the storyline for this game was weak. This game is kind of a departure from the survival horror theme/genre.

This game is reletively easy to complete, except boss fights like fighting the bogeyman,on hard dificulty/hard puzzle difficulty was extremely hard for me. I got stuck there and eventually sold the game, although if I got past that then, I would have completed most of the stupid side missions that are only worth 5 Gamerscore. The difficulty in the game affects the location of puzzle items, that you need to find, and how difficult it is to beat a boss in the game. For example on easy difficulty, when I fought the bogeyman, I had a handgun, and lots of health, on hard dificulty I had a fireaxe, and barely any health, it was impossible. At least Silent Hill Homecing still has the creepy survival horror feeling, that game was slighty better, than Downpour.

I've started playing the HD Collection, myself so far it is good. If you like survival horror games then you'll like this series and resident evil among others.

Kizaru Jiruga 04-06-2013 11:44 PM

mmmm... downpour is a very good game, but if you like the old times you choose will be HD collection

Miss Allen86 04-26-2013 03:34 PM

If you played the original games 1, 2, 3, 4 and then you play Downpour, you'll notice a big change from then to now. I believe the newer Silent Hill title are developed by a different company along side Konami of course but the changes in Downpour are noticeable. Downpour to me seemed more action filled and had you using weapons alot more often as for the older ones were more like a puzzle solving mind F game. Anyway enough of my ranting. Play the HD collection their classics but also play Downpour. Their all great games. ;)

Neme6ben 04-28-2013 12:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Miss Allen86 (Post 5732307)
If you played the original games 1, 2, 3, 4 and then you play Downpour, you'll notice a big change from then to now. I believe the newer Silent Hill title are developed by a different company along side Konami of course but the changes in Downpour are noticeable. Downpour to me seemed more action filled and had you using weapons alot more often as for the older ones were more like a puzzle solving mind F game. Anyway enough of my ranting. Play the HD collection their classics but also play Downpour. Their all great games. ;)

actually Downpour has less action than even Silent Hill 2 imo, the best example of this is that there is an achievement for completing the game without killing a monster. Most of the time you run from monsters in this game, you don't find alot of ammo and can't carry lots of guns as well.

Back to the subject though, I recommand you to play the HD Collection first!

cutterk73 04-28-2013 01:24 PM

what about the bug and glitches in the hd collection? anything game breaking?

Neme6ben 05-02-2013 12:19 PM

the first time you're playing there isn't any game breaking bugs, but when you finish them a few times, the endings stacks and then it gets really buggy, I couldn't pick up an item without the game freezing every single time, I had to erase all my saved files :(

Stifler4Life 06-05-2013 06:36 PM

The glitches in the collection are a serious issue and the new voice actors really do an awful job representing the characters.

Downpour isn't great but it's a step in the right direction.

Try Downpour first.

Skip Homecoming, you're not missing out.


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:16 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.