XboxAchievements.com

XboxAchievements.com (http://www.xboxachievements.com/forum/index.php)
-   Silent Hill: Downpour (http://www.xboxachievements.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=1841)
-   -   Does this game get good? (http://www.xboxachievements.com/forum/showthread.php?t=369598)

zhoban 05-10-2012 06:48 PM

Does this game get good?
 
So far, I haven't found an ounce of good yet and I'm at the end of the Radio Station where I am getting ready for a escape that is very reminiscent of Silent Hill: Shattered Memories and I have to deal with a glitch where I need to go back into the Radio Station to get the Diluent and there is a open door yet there is also a closed door so I have to close the open door then open the closed door. And even aside from that, the game is so bogged down by terrible puzzles that require almost little to no thought, terrible chase scenes that are more frustrating than scary, poor enemy design, choices thrown into the game that don't even matter, terrible framerate and just any other problems that would make a game seem bad.

That being said, is there some point (hopefully soon) where I start thinking it is good? Hopefully this game doesn't do the same exact thing as Silent Hill: Origins, Silent Hill: Homecoming and Silent Hill: Shattered Memories did by randomly throwing in a Silent Hill 2 plot twist.

Nemesis Sieg 06-16-2012 11:36 PM

"Does this game get good?" Bluntly (but honestly) not really. I'm a big fan of Silent Hill, and games of a similar type but when it came to Downpour I was just wanting to be done with it by the radio station. Some of it is great, I love the outside area and the heavy rain but it hardly evens out the negatives. Every area I went to I couldn't wait to leave. The combat is so bad, the frame rate problems although it only happened occasionally were irritating. There had been the odd glitch, I experienced the door one also. I just finished my hard playthrough going through as quickly as I can, my end playtime was 2 hours 46 mins. Just one more playthrough to get my full gamescore but when I do think of Silent Hill, Downpour certainly won't come into my thoughts. Thankfully I bought the HD collection also so that will win me back over after this game gets shelved.

zhoban 06-17-2012 03:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nemesis Sieg (Post 5126986)
"Does this game get good?" Bluntly (but honestly) not really. I'm a big fan of Silent Hill, and games of a similar type but when it came to Downpour I was just wanting to be done with it by the radio station. Some of it is great, I love the outside area and the heavy rain but it hardly evens out the negatives. Every area I went to I couldn't wait to leave. The combat is so bad, the frame rate problems although it only happened occasionally were irritating. There had been the odd glitch, I experienced the door one also. I just finished my hard playthrough going through as quickly as I can, my end playtime was 2 hours 46 mins. Just one more playthrough to get my full gamescore but when I do think of Silent Hill, Downpour certainly won't come into my thoughts. Thankfully I bought the HD collection also so that will win me back over after this game gets shelved.

Even though I knew I was about five minutes from the end, I was at that final Otherworld sequence, I took that game back. The game was an absolute abysmal failure in every area, I couldn't find an ounce of fun or good in the game. The combat was button mashing, it was Silent Hill: Homecoming but somehow worse which I didn't think that was possible.

At first, I was glad they were putting in references to the old games but then it became a constant reference to Silent Hill: Homecoming and I just kept getting more and more agitated because they were boasting how much like old Silent Hill it was going to be. However, the only thing I noticed resembling the old Silent Hill games were the references.

I wouldn't recommend that game, Silent Hill 2 is my favorite game and I just felt disappointed when they released that HD Collection. I would recommend looking up a video on why that HD Collection is bad.

Chaos MAN 06-21-2012 02:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zhoban (Post 5127983)
Even though I knew I was about five minutes from the end, I was at that final Otherworld sequence, I took that game back.

.

You should have finished it. The last boss fight was the coolest thing in the game.

zhoban 06-21-2012 04:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chaos MAN (Post 5134205)
You should have finished it. The last boss fight was the coolest thing in the game.

That wouldn't be hard, I didn't find anything cool about the game. The game just wasn't fun. Granted Silent Hill to Silent Hill 3 didn't have the great combat, but there was so much more to them that made them great. And even their combat system was better than the terrible combat in Silent Hill: Downpour. Honestly, I would have even rather have dealt with my biggest complaint about Silent Hill 4: The Room and just sat there backtracking in that game than play this awful game.

jamesbong1983 10-03-2012 04:49 PM

What's good about this game

1. The script of the game is more like a movie.
2. There are slight improvement in graphics
3. (Some of you may disagree) I like the idea of carrying 1 melee weapon at a time, it makes me feel more like reality.
4. Side quests

What's bad about this game

Story

1. The game has a complete storyline. (Murphy want to revenge for his son dead end up harming a good man as well) But I think the game should describe more on the following areas:

(a) Relationship between Murphy and his wife Carol
(b) Why Murphy should be partially responsible for his son dead
(c) Why Frank is a good man, and harming him will make Murphy feel guilty.
(d) How does the story fit with the title of the game "Downpour"

Gameplay

1. Poor combat system
2. It destroy the whole idea of otherworld. Otherworld should be a weird place with lots of monsters, but not a place full of traps.

zhoban 02-28-2013 08:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jamesbong1983 (Post 5305702)
What's good about this game

1. The script of the game is more like a movie.
2. There are slight improvement in graphics
3. (Some of you may disagree) I like the idea of carrying 1 melee weapon at a time, it makes me feel more like reality.
4. Side quests

What's bad about this game

Story

1. The game has a complete storyline. (Murphy want to revenge for his son dead end up harming a good man as well) But I think the game should describe more on the following areas:

(a) Relationship between Murphy and his wife Carol
(b) Why Murphy should be partially responsible for his son dead
(c) Why Frank is a good man, and harming him will make Murphy feel guilty.
(d) How does the story fit with the title of the game "Downpour"

Gameplay

1. Poor combat system
2. It destroy the whole idea of otherworld. Otherworld should be a weird place with lots of monsters, but not a place full of traps.

I finally decided to pick this game up and I'm at the very end. The last time I rented it, I got all the way to the final chase sequence and I gave up because of the awful checkpoint system.

That being said, I have nothing good to say about this game. I didn't have an ounce of fun with it.

nomsheep 02-28-2013 08:37 PM

Not really no. This game is just awful.

Legrand 03-14-2013 02:20 AM

If you manage to beat the game once for a second play-through the secret ending is well worth it...

Fire Mage 04-25-2013 05:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jamesbong1983 (Post 5305702)
What's bad about this game

Story

Thanks for the great spoilers there buddy!

I just started the game and was just looking around a few posts and now I already know the reasoning behind Murphy (at least what bit of it I read) which is pretty essential to the story of these games and why the characters are drawn to Silent Hill.

Fuck.

Neme6ben 04-28-2013 12:54 PM

The main problem I have with this game is the otherworld, in previous SH games, OW was creepy and made you stop playing sometimes, you didn't want to go further for a few minutes lol, but in Downpour it goes so fast you don't have time to see what the otherworld is about, it's a shame!

AgentXLVII 07-22-2013 05:01 AM

Best thing about this game was the story.


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:21 PM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.