You have to do ALL the hunting missions manual, means not using the glitch for the hunting. With that glitch you can only choose the last one, so you only have 10% percent for the hunting.
EDIT: I add the locations of the animals, you can still use the glitch but NOT for the hunting missions. Just go, after every killed animal (a total of 6), back to indian hunter to pick up the next mission.
Grey Wolf - The Plains just past the bridge leading out of Dodge City, or to the west of the ranch in the badlands.
Great White Bufallo - The Field in the badlands where all the other bufallo are.
White Wolf - By Piper Lake or by the stream next to the Indian Trader.
Great Mountain Lion - By a hut in the deserty bit past piper lake.
Black Wolf - Either behind the Mine in the badlands or over a little hills into a little secluded area next to the ranch.
Grizzly - Just Outside Empire on the edge of the badlands outside the tunnel then it runs to its cave on the edge of empire.
Last edited by LH Cerberus; 06-03-2010 at 11:30 PM.