Personally I have always loved Dead or Alive Ultimate, Power Stone 2, Def Jam Fight for NY, and anything Street Fighter. Some of the VS series games were good too like Marvel Super Heroes vs Street Fighter and X-Men vs Street Fighter. Can't forget Street Fighter Alpha 3 either or Project Justice!
There are so many 360 fighting games that it's hard for me to compile a list of the best ones! My list would be too partial to Street Fighter anyway so I will try and diversify it for those looking for a good fighting game and not just Street Fighter. If I HAD to choose my top Xbox 360 fighting games for Retail and Xbox Live Aracde it would be:
Top Retail Fighters
1. Super Street Fighter IV Arcade Edition
2. Mortal Kombat 9
3. Ultimate Marvel vs Capcom 3
4. Dead or Alive 4
Top Arcade Fighters
1. Street Fighter III: Online Edition
2. NeoGeo Battle Colliseum
3. Super Street Fighter II Turbo HD Remix
4. King of Fighters 98'
If you're not a 2-D kind of guy then check out Soul Calibur, Virtua Fighter 5 and Tekken 6. NeoGeo Battle Colliseum really impressed me gameplay-wise so I put it at #2. If you like BlazBlue then you should definitely try Battle Fantasia. The Naruto games are worth checking out too but I think Naruto Storm II is the only one actually recognized as a fighting game.
Just find out what you like don't take our opinions seriously. Everybody is different!
Last edited by FeLizP; 11-04-2011 at 10:59 PM.