I think people say RE4, and RE5 is the best simply because they like a game to be made easy for them without a real challenge. Classic RE games are the real Resident Evil. 4&5 didn't have the horror. I think its funny too how they say "oh man the controls for RE1-3 are terrible" thats how they should be, not a easy control scheme where anybody could play. Resident Evil Remake is the best out there and nothing will ever top it.