OMG that was it.
Like you say it turns out that if you press the button TOO QUICKLY it ignores all the presses. So when I retried it and pressed it at half speed I made it easily.
Seems like they hate turbo contorllers - and people that can press the button very fast (like unfortunatley I had been).
Thanks for the reply, I have been able to get all S Ranks now.
BTW, this game is AWESOME! I have over 1200 xbox 360 games, this has to be top 5!
Started collecting achievements in July 2008. If Im not on Xbox then Im playing PS3, WII or PC.
Last edited by The Dauntless; 03-18-2012 at 12:23 AM.