I'd give it a 6.5. It is a good game for it's time. The gameplay, graphics, and sound are decent. I liked the story. I am only annoyed that you can't skip through cut-scenes and evidence report sequences; especially when you are replaying a chapter. It's well worth the money to pick it up used these days, and the achievements aren't bad at all.
Please send me a message first if you add me on XBL.