Originally Posted by Elarris
But that only shows the two squadmates that were with shepherd not the rest of them. I'm assuming that James was the one who told Joker to leave shepherd behind when the crucible was firing, and Negative Creep was wondering how he got there as he wasn't one of the two that were extracted. Am I right or at least close?
That could be what he was saying, but I doubt it considering that was never considered a plothole prior to Extended Cut. It's generally assumed that all of the squadmates you don't bring with you during part two of Priority Earth returned to the Normandy.