Loved the game
I picked this game up brand new for $10 on a clearance sale and had a blast with it. It had some issues, most notably freezes (I encountered this twice & had to shut the console off and restart from a checkpoint) and a glitchy new game + (read some forums before trying it! I blew mine and had to replay to get the full 1000). I loved the story, which was written by Mike Carey, who actually wrote a number of the recent X-Men Legacy comics. I agree that a $60 price tag was probably a bit steep for the game length, but for me this was worth more than the $10 I paid. It was also a fairly easy 1000 gamerscore with the tips from the guides.