|Start a game using "Play Now" and leave the settings as is. As the description states, score a touchdown on defense. The achievement will unlock once you meet the requirements. You do not have to complete a full game.|
Two Controller Method:
As controller one (main profile,) play on defense. Using controller two, select a play type and hike the ball. Then, move the quarterback around and use the defender with controller one to hit him hard and cause a fumble then run it back for a touchdown. Alternatively, make an interception and run the ball back for a touchdown.