Jump to content

 

Rate the signature above you


Xerofox
 Share

Recommended Posts

http://gfxuploader.com/images/lz66ssdybjt60k2cao.png

 

 

 

Since the original thread derailed, we have decided to start a new thread with some ground rules to stop the stream of spam. This thread is simple, rate the signature of the member above you. You don't have to go into lighting, C4D's, flow, text/render placement or brushes as long as you give your opinion about what you like/dislike.

 

 

 

http://gfxuploader.com/images/iyflxuccefegoxi1zii3.png

 

 

  • Only rate the signature directly above you
  • The signature you are rating must be in a quote
  • Rate between 1 - 10, no more 9999/10 ratings here
  • To your best knowledge give (constructive) feedback about what to like/dislike
  • Be fair, most people have put a lot of effort into an image so if you don't like or know an artist/band/game/movie/anime/show don't bother responding
  • Only rate when you have a signature of your own, no gamercards here unless it's super awesome
  • Only post if you can handle feedback
  • Wait until 2 other members have posted before you post again
  • You are allowed to post a different signature, please say you want that signature rated instead of your current one
  • No discussions here. We all like each other, remember?
  • You are allowed to quote an earlier post as long as you follow the rules

 

Enjoy and please rate mine :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 273
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

http://gfxuploader.com/images/y1i3t068nstxc95u1jf.png

 

Guess I'll be the first one here after you. (Second I know, leave me alone).

 

I would give that a 9/10.

 

No idea where it's from but I like the colours and everything.

 

10/10

 

That size is better.

 

I'm on an iPad so I can't quote sigs, sorry. I will quote the reply above so it can be easily navigated to and see the sig.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

One of your best backgrounds for sure. The C4D or whatever you used looks like it has been erased in random places so it looks a little patchy in certain spots.

 

Also the bottom border of the sig looks a little weird. Like a slice in the piece that looks like a complete accident.

 

8/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One of your best backgrounds for sure. The C4D or whatever you used looks like it has been erased in random places so it looks a little patchy in certain spots.

 

Also the bottom border of the sig looks a little weird. Like a slice in the piece that looks like a complete accident.

 

8/10

 

I'm not sure how that happened tbh. Are you talking about how the blue cuts off abruptly?

 

I give yours a 9/10. I wish it was a little bit bigger, especially since its partially transparent. Text is awesome, and the render is clean and of a good quality. One of your best pieces for sure. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not sure how that happened tbh. Are you talking about how the blue cuts off abruptly?

 

I give yours a 9/10. I wish it was a little bit bigger, especially since its partially transparent. Text is awesome, and the render is clean and of a good quality. One of your best pieces for sure. :)

 

I give yours a 9/10.

 

Looks great but I personally don't like the small black stripe at the top and bottom. Otherwise, it's fantastic. :dance:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

http://gfxuploader.com/images/zymsnjk5boptfwsbdg.gif

 

6/10

 

I personally know nothing of DMC to enjoy the theme going on, and I also am not a fan of "pop-out" thingies in signatures like the sword on the bottom.

 

3/10

 

Really don't like it, and you usually have awesome sigs. I know it's a comedic sig, but I can't appreciate it.

 

Just looks cheap and tacky impo. Sorry dude (return to your awesome batman sigs, they are 10/10)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't know much about Deus Ex, but the sig is all one color, and the color's pretty bland. Not one of your greater works. 6.0/10

6/10

 

I'm assuming this is DMC, in which case I'm not a huge fan, but the sig itself is nice. The design, the sword at the bottom and the colours are all very slick. A solid 6.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6/10

 

I'm assuming this is DMC, in which case I'm not a huge fan, but the sig itself is nice. The design, the sword at the bottom and the colours are all very slick. A solid 6.

 

6.5/10

 

Really don't like the focal, even though I saw that it was per request. I'm also not a fan of the background, but I like the color gradient in the text and the sparkle animation on it. A very solid 6.5/10. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://gfxuploader.com/images/zymsnjk5boptfwsbdg.gif

 

9/10

 

Overall really good sig. I like the color scheme, the text is good, solid use of the render and I definitely like the added touch with the sparkling. I feel as though the weakest part of the sig is the background; but its still quite a nice signature.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://i.imgur.com/gadcf0j.png

 

Dark Magician for the win!! But, sadly I don't like the rest of it very much.

 

You would think with the Magician's outfit being purple and all, the rest of the sig's colour scheme would also be purple, not green. However, the effects are top notch; they compliment the digital-esque form the card battles take place on.

 

I know you guys are all about text, and this text is in the right place, but I just don't like it. It seems like it was forced there for lack of better integration.

 

However, 8.2/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://i.imgur.com/qyx3MbK.jpg

9/10

 

Nice and colorful. Just feels like its missing something, not quite sure. Its a very nice sig though.

 

http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e38/socomshooter/8lcgvg487y6td4rkotoo_zps5c43e1bd.png

 

9/10.

 

-1 point because i don't know where it's from. :p

 

  • Be fair, most people have put a lot of effort into an image so if you don't like or know an artist/band/game/movie/anime/show don't bother responding

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://i.imgur.com/gadcf0j.png

 

6/10

 

I really like the render of the Dark Magician, but something about this signature feels off. The font doesn't capture my attention, and if I didn't know your account name, the "BEA" is somewhat hard to read. The background also shows potential with the design, but for me, the colors seem off :/ Definitely solid work though, it's just the front size and background colors that are off-putting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://gfxuploader.com/images/45ip4somlt34pm72hw5.jpg

 

9.5

 

Artistic and colorful. The character feels like he is part of the piece not just slapped on a background. My only issue is with the font chosen, just doesn't feel right.

Edited by KillerBEA
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
  • Create New...